GUIDE
ATR or KBr (transmission) in FTIR: measurement physics and spectral consequences
The same material produces different spectra depending on the technique. Comparing an ATR spectrum with a transmission library requires a quantitative understanding of what changes and why.
- ATR is fast and requires little preparation; KBr is the reference technique in traditional libraries and requires grinding and attention to water.
- In ATR, low-wavenumber bands become relatively stronger because light penetrates farther at longer wavelengths.
- Compare spectra measured with the same technique; comparison of ATR with a KBr library is screening only.
- Hydrochlorides can exchange halide in KBr: prefer ATR or KCl pellets.
1. What changes
Lesson 1: What is spectroscopy?Lesson 2: What is light?Molecular vibrations
| Aspect | ATR (attenuated total reflection) | Transmission (KBr, film) |
|---|---|---|
| Preparation | little or none: the sample is pressed against the crystal | KBr pellet, film or cell; requires grinding and mixing |
| Intensities | penetration depth increases with wavelength: low-wavenumber bands become stronger | intensity proportional to thickness and concentration (Beer–Lambert law) |
| Band positions | tend to be a few cm⁻¹ lower (2–4 cm⁻¹ for strong bands) | reference technique in traditional libraries |
| Water and artifacts | limited interference; irregular contact changes intensity | KBr is hygroscopic: bands at ≈ 3400 and 1640 may come from water in the salt |
| Samples | solids, powders, liquids, films and pastes | requires a dispersible or film-forming sample; very strong bands saturate |
2. The evanescent wave and penetration depth
In ATR, light undergoes total reflection in the crystal; only an evanescent field extends into the sample, reaching a depth of a few micrometers. This depth increases with wavelength: consequently, the same band is stronger at lower wavenumbers (for diamond, about threefold between 3000 and 1000 cm⁻¹).
Explore further: the equation for dp, numerical values and the condition for total reflection
In ATR, the beam undergoes total internal reflection at the crystal–sample interface if the incidence angle θ exceeds the critical angle, θc = arcsin(n₂/n₁), where n₁ and n₂ are the crystal and sample refractive indices. An evanescent field penetrates the sample with exponentially decaying amplitude; the depth at which its amplitude falls to 1/e is:
dp = λ / [ 2π n₁ √( sin²θ − (n₂/n₁)² ) ]
where λ is the vacuum wavelength. Because dp is proportional to λ, the same band is stronger at lower wavenumbers. For a diamond crystal (n₁ ≈ 2.4), an organic sample with n₂ ≈ 1.5 and θ = 45°, dp ≈ 0.67 µm at 3000 cm⁻¹, 1.18 µm at 1700 cm⁻¹, 2.0 µm at 1000 cm⁻¹ and 2.9 µm at 700 cm⁻¹: a band at 1000 cm⁻¹ is about three times as intense as a band at 3000 cm⁻¹ with the same ε and concentration. For germanium (n₁ ≈ 4.0), penetration falls to about one-third (≈ 0.66 µm at 1000 cm⁻¹). Values depend on sample refractive index, angle and number of reflections; the effective thickness, which determines measured absorbance, is proportional to dp, with factors that depend on polarization.
Total-reflection condition. With diamond (n₁ ≈ 2.4) and θ = 45°, θc is ≈ 38.7° for n₂ = 1.5 but ≈ 45.1° for n₂ = 1.7; high-index samples, such as some minerals and pigments, may violate this condition and produce distorted spectra, in which case a germanium crystal is appropriate.
3. Choosing a crystal
| Crystal | n (approx.) | Useful range (cm⁻¹, approx.) | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|
| Diamond | 2,4 | ≈ 7800 to 400, with intrinsic two-phonon lattice absorption between ≈ 2600 and 1900, stronger at 2300–1900 | highly resistant and chemically inert; a routine choice |
| Zinc selenide (ZnSe) | 2,4 | ≈ 20 000 a 650 | sensitive to strong acids and bases and to scratching; more fragile |
| Germanium | 4,0 | ≈ 5500 a 600 | shallower penetration: suitable for dark, strongly absorbing and high-index samples |
4. ATR correction and band positions
FTIR software offers ATR correction to compensate for this wavelength dependence and bring intensities closer to a transmission spectrum. This helps library comparison but does not replace measuring the reference with the same technique. Strong bands may also appear a few cm⁻¹ lower in ATR.
Explore further: anomalous dispersion and Kramers–Kronig
FTIR software offers ATR correction to compensate for the dependence of dp on wavelength and, in some cases, for sample-index dispersion; it brings relative intensities closer to those of a transmission spectrum. Correction helps library comparison but does not replace measuring the reference with the same technique. Strong bands may also shift to lower wavenumbers and become asymmetric because the refractive index changes rapidly near a strong band (anomalous dispersion, related to absorption through the Kramers–Kronig relations). Stronger bands generally show larger shifts of a few cm⁻¹.
5. Artifacts and precautions in transmission (KBr)
- Water. KBr is hygroscopic; bands at ≈ 3400 and 1640 cm⁻¹ may come from the salt. Check with a blank pellet.
- Scattering and the Christiansen effect. Particles larger than the wavelength scatter radiation and tilt the baseline, with asymmetric bands; grind the sample to particles of about 2 µm or smaller.
- Ion exchange and pressure. Halide salts can exchange anions with KBr during grinding and pressing (a hydrochloride may partially form the hydrobromide, changing the spectrum; for hydrochlorides, prefer KCl or ATR). Pressure can convert polymorphs or hydrates.
- Saturation. Very strong bands saturate; reduce the concentration.
In ATR, irregular contact changes intensity (use reproducible pressure, preferably with the accessory torque device). Anisotropic or very hard samples may give different spectra at different positions.
6. Which technique to choose and how to compare
For routine work, diamond ATR is the most practical option: fast, reproducible and without preparation. Transmission remains useful for quantification at controlled thickness and comparison with older libraries. The most important point is to use the same technique for sample and reference.
- Record the technique, resolution, scan count, instrument and whether ATR correction was applied.
- Compare equal ranges using the same baseline treatment.
- When comparing an ATR spectrum with a transmission library, treat the result as screening.
References
- Harrick, N. J. Internal Reflection Spectroscopy. New York: Interscience (Wiley), 1967.
- Mirabella, F. M. (ed.). Internal Reflection Spectroscopy: Theory and Applications. New York: Marcel Dekker, 1992 (reissued by CRC Press).
- Griffiths, P. R.; de Haseth, J. A. Fourier Transform Infrared Spectrometry. 2nd ed. Hoboken: Wiley-Interscience, 2007.
- Stuart, B. H. Infrared Spectroscopy: Fundamentals and Applications. Chichester: Wiley, 2004.
Frequently asked questions
Can I compare an ATR spectrum with a KBr library?
Yes, for screening. Relative intensities and positions change somewhat, so spectra measured with the same technique are preferable.
Why are low-wavenumber bands stronger in ATR?
Because evanescent-wave penetration depth is proportional to wavelength; at lower wavenumbers, the field penetrates farther into the sample and effective thickness is greater.
Is the broad band at 3400 cm⁻¹ always from the sample?
In KBr pellets, part of it may come from water absorbed by the salt. Check with a blank pellet.
Why can a hydrochloride spectrum change in KBr?
Because chloride in the salt can be exchanged for bromide during grinding and pressing. For hydrochlorides, ATR or KCl pellets are a safer choice for preserving the original salt spectrum.
Ranges are typical tabulated values and vary with technique, physical state, matrix and instrument. This guide describes functional groups and compatible classes; it does not identify substances.